New Dietary Guidelines lack clear message on less meat, more plants
Administration ignores Scientific Advisory Panel’s call for sustainable diets
WASHINGTON, D.C. – The Obama administration’s newly released 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines for Americans fail to provide clear guidance to the public around lowering meat consumption, despite strong scientific evidence presented by its own Advisory Committee on the need for Americans to eat less meat for health, food security and environmental reasons. More than 21,000 public comments, 700 health professionals, and hundreds of mayors have expressed support for the Committee’s recommendations on the importance of diets with less meat and more plant-based foods.
The Dietary Guidelines, which are widely promoted to the public, help guide nutrition education programs and menu planning for government institutions, including schools, prisons, military facilities and federal cafeterias.
“Given the huge health and environmental costs of diets high in factory farmed meat, the lack of clear guidance on lowering meat consumption does a disservice to the public and our future food security,” said Kari Hamerschlag, senior program manager with Friends of the Earth. “The administration has clearly put the financial interests of the meat industry over the weight of the science and the health of the American people.”
While none of the Key Recommendations specifically urge less meat consumption, the findings and portion size recommendations buried deep in the report suggest that Americans do in fact need to be eating less meat. For example, the report says “Lower intakes of meats…have often been identified as characteristics of healthy eating patterns,” and that “Some individuals, especially teen boys and adult men, need to reduce…protein foods by decreasing intakes of meats, poultry, and eggs and increasing amounts of vegetables…” Also for the first time, the Guidelines highlight a meat-free vegetarian diet as one of three healthy eating patterns.
The new guidelines also indicate a recommended maximum weekly intake of 26 ounces of meat, poultry and eggs — or 3.7 ounces per day for a 2000 calorie diet. The guidelines, however fail to note that the average person in 2013 ate 6 ounces of those foods a day, according to USDA ERS data, 40 per cent more than is recommended.
“It’s astonishing that the new Dietary Guidelines, which are supposed to help clarify what people should eat, are actually obscuring science-based recommendations that Americans should significantly cut their red meat intake,” Hamerschlag added. “Despite clear evidence that high red meat consumption is linked to cancer and threatens future food security because of its huge resource demands, the 2015 Guidelines failed to make a specific portion size recommendation for red meat, as they did in the 2010 Guidelines.”
Since the February 2015 release of the Advisory Committee’s Scientific Report, there has been unprecedented civic engagement, including an outpouring of public support for recommendations on environmental sustainability and diets with less meat and more plants:
- Nearly 75 percent of the 29,000 public comments submitted to USDA/HHS favored less meat, more plants and sustainability;
- A petition to USDA and HHS from 12 organizations garnered more than 150,000 signatories.
- A letter from 49 major health, public interest and environmental organizations was delivered to USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack and HHS Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell.
- A joint statement was signed by more than 150 environmental and health organizations and experts in support of sustainability, less meat, and more plant-based foods.
- A letter of support was sent to Secretaries Vilsack and Burwell by more than 700 health professionals, including Yale University’s Dr. David Katz and Harvard University’s Dr. Walter Willett.
- A resolution adopted by the U.S. Conference of Mayors and a letter from a subset of mayors was delivered to USDA and HHS supporting the inclusion of sustainability considerations.
Consumer trends and attitudes, as well as increased vegetarian options in the marketplace demonstrate that the public is ready for guidelines recommending less meat and more plant-based diets:
- One in ten Millennials follows a vegetarian diet.
- Forty-seven percent of the population eats at least one meal without meat per week, up from 40 percent six years earlier.
- Between 26 and 41 percent of Americans have eaten less meat over the past year.
- Restaurants such as Panera Bread and Taco Bell are offering more vegetarian options.
The Obama administration’s rejection of environmental sustainability in the Guidelines was expected. In October 2015, USDA and HHS released a blog post stating that sustainability considerations were outside of the purview of the DGAs. However, a legal analysis commissioned by My Plate My Planet makes clear that statute itself in no way precludes the inclusion of sustainability considerations in the guidelines.
Note to editors: More background on Friends of the Earth’s comments and prior releases on the Dietary Guidelines can be found here.
Expert contact: Kari Hamerschlag, (510) 978-4420, [email protected]
Communications contact: Kate Colwell, (202) 222-0744, [email protected]